Single-Source Risk and Second Supplier Calculator
Work out the annual cost of building a second source for a single-sourced item, the expected loss it prevents, and the outage probability at which the decision turns.
Calculator
The annual cost of building a second source for a single-sourced item, the expected loss it prevents, and the outage probability at which the decision turns.
Result
Prices are labelled TRY because that is the currency we quote in. The arithmetic is linear, so if you enter your own unit prices in another currency the totals come back in that same currency — read the suffix as your currency, not ours.
The calculation runs entirely in your browser; nothing you type is sent to our servers. Only if you press “Request a quote with this calculation” are your inputs and the result written to your browser’s session storage, so it can be carried into the quote form.
Worked example
Opened with its default case — Probability that supply is interrupted within a year (%): 15 · How many days would you be left without an alternative?: 30 · Daily cost of an interruption (TRY/day): 12000 — the calculator returns the figures below. The headline result is BUILD THE SECOND SOURCE — 4,667 TRY better off per year (verdict). They are written out here so the output is readable without running JavaScript: in print, with scripts disabled, or by a search engine.
| Input | Value |
|---|---|
| Probability that supply is interrupted within a year (%) | 15 |
| How many days would you be left without an alternative? | 30 |
| Daily cost of an interruption (TRY/day) | 12000 |
| One-off cost of building the second source (TRY) | 40000 |
| Over how many years do you spread that cost? | 3 |
| Annual recurring cost of the second source (TRY/yr) | 18000 |
| Probability that both sources fail (%) | 3 |
| Switch-over time to the second source (days) | 5 |
| Result | Value |
|---|---|
| Situation | A stoppage costs 360,000 TRY in total · expected value 54,000 TRY/yr |
| Expected annual outage cost — single source | 54,000 TRY |
| Expected annual outage cost — two sources | 18,000 TRY |
| Annual risk saving | 36,000 TRY |
| Annual cost of the second source | 31,333 TRY (set-up 13,333 TRY/yr + recurring 18,000 TRY) |
| Net annual effect | 4,667 TRY in favour |
| Verdict | BUILD THE SECOND SOURCE — 4,667 TRY better off per year |
| Break-even outage probability | 13.4% — a second source pays off if your outage probability is ABOVE this (assuming the both-fail probability you entered stays put) |
| Payback on the one-off set-up | 2.2 years |
Change any field above and the calculator recomputes; this table is the default case only. Money figures come from the example values pre-filled in the fields; the tool embeds no market prices — enter your own figures, VAT excluded.
When does single sourcing stop being risky and start being expensive?
Single sourcing is not wrong in itself. Keeping the volume in one place genuinely pays on price, on transaction cost and on the relationship. What is wrong is not putting a number against the cost of an interruption.
The decision is a single comparison. The annual cost of building and keeping a second source — the one-off set-up divided by the years you spread it over, plus the recurring annual extra — is set against the reduction in expected outage cost. That reduction is the expected annual outage cost with one source minus the expected cost that remains with two, because a second source does not remove the risk, it shrinks it. If the annual cost is smaller than that reduction, the second source pays. Expected cost is the product of three numbers: outage probability × outage days × daily cost. If one of the three is small, a second source may not pay; if outage days and daily cost are both large, the set-up cost can come back on a single interruption avoided.
Expected cost, and how it differs from a guess
“It would be very bad if this supplier let us down” does not produce a decision, because there is no number to set against it. Expected cost produces exactly that number: the annual value, today, of an event that may not happen.
Expected annual outage cost = Outage probability × Outage days × Daily cost
Each of the three inputs has its own difficulty. Probability is not measured, it is estimated — but it can be estimated: how many deliveries ran late last year, how many times the supplier said “no stock”, whether production sits in one plant, whether imports come through one port. Days are easily underestimated: finding a new supplier is not the slow part, approving one is. Daily cost may already be known inside the company — downtime cost, contractual penalty, or the premium paid when something has to be bought in a hurry.
The tool’s most useful output is not the verdict but the break-even probability, and it is worth knowing exactly how it is built, because it is not simply “cost ÷ exposure”. With two sources the expected cost has two parts: when only the first source fails you lose the switch-over days; when both fail you lose the full outage days. Setting the saving equal to the annual cost gives:
Break-even outage probability = Probability that both sources fail + Annual cost of the second source ÷ ((Outage days − Switch-over days) × Daily cost)
Read it as a threshold: if your own estimate of the outage probability is above that figure, a second source pays — holding the both-fail probability you entered constant. Saying which side of a threshold you are on is far easier than defending an abstract percentage.
A risk matrix: which item sits in which cell
You do not build a second source for every item — if you try, the buying team spends its time keeping second sources alive instead of buying. Splitting items on two axes puts the effort where it belongs: the impact of an interruption and how easily an alternative is found.
| Impact of an interruption | Alternatives are plentiful (shelf item) | Alternatives are scarce (bespoke, no substitute) |
|---|---|---|
| LOW — stock covers it, nothing stops | Do not build a second source. Keeping the volume in one place is a clear gain here; the alternative is already on the market. | Solve it with stock. Here safety stock can be the cheaper answer than building a second source. |
| HIGH — production or service stops, penalties run | An approved standby is enough: identify a second supplier, get their price and lead time, approve their sample — place no regular order, just a small keep-alive order once a year. Low cost, short switch-over. | 🔴 Build a real second source. This is the only cell where the calculation on this page needs to be made; in the other three the answer is already known. |
The matrix is a decision frame for prioritising effort, not a rule from any standard. The number of items that land in the bottom-right cell may be smaller than you expect — list them first, then run the calculation only for those.
The costs of a second source that nobody budgets
The set-up cost is easy to estimate; the cost of keeping the source alive is the one that gets missed. A second source is not something you build once and put on a shelf — it decays unless it is used.
- The discount lost when volume is split. The same total spend divided between two suppliers drops you a tier with both. This can be a large item, and because it never appears on an invoice it is easily missed.
- A second quality file. Samples, test reports, certificate tracking and audits double, and they repeat every year.
- The keep-alive order. A second source that never receives an order will say “we don’t know you” on the day you need it. The cost of one small order a year is the subscription fee for a second source.
- Two different products. If the two suppliers’ goods are not identical, two separate records appear in the warehouse, in production and in the specification; a substitution difference is not something you write down once and forget.
Against that, a second source also has a benefit on the price side that is easily left out of the sum: the existence of a genuine alternative caps what the first supplier can ask for. That benefit was left out of the calculator because it cannot be measured — but read the net figure knowing that it works in favour of the second source.
“Two sources” is not always two sources
The easy way to work out the chance of both suppliers failing at once is to multiply the two probabilities — 15% × 15% = 2.25%. That multiplication is only correct if the two sources are independent of each other, and in purchasing they are not always so.
- They may both be distributors for the same manufacturer — when the manufacturer stops, both stop.
- They may both import from the same country through the same port; a customs or freight crisis hits both.
- They may both depend on the same raw material; in a shortage the source you were holding as an alternative has none either.
- They may both depend on the same document — when an import licence or a permit is suspended, neither can supply.
That is why the calculator does not do the multiplication for you: it asks. If even one of the points above applies, the both-fail probability you enter should be markedly higher than the product of the two.
Caution: For the same reason, choose the second source for where it differs: a different manufacturer, a different country, a different port or a different raw material. Finding a second name does not reduce risk; finding a different route does.
Three cheap measures to use instead
When the calculation says no, the answer is not to ignore the risk. Three measures cost a fraction of a real second source and are enough everywhere except the bottom-right cell of the matrix.
- An approved standby, with no regular orders. Identify the second supplier, approve their sample, get their current price and lead time in writing; place no regular orders, just a small keep-alive order once a year. Costs little and shortens the switch-over.
- Targeted safety stock. Not on every item, only on those in the right-hand column of the matrix (few alternatives). It does not shorten the interruption, it reduces its impact.
- A notice clause in the contract. An obligation on the supplier to give advance warning of a stock-out is the cheapest measure that shortens an interruption; it costs one sentence.
What the tool says when the answer is no
The calculator is built to be able to say no, and to say so out loud rather than quietly trimming a number. Five cases are reported in words instead of a figure.
- The second source does not reduce risk. If the expected cost with two sources is not lower than with one — the switch-over is not shorter than the outage, or the both-fail probability equals the single-source probability — the tool says a second source does not reduce risk with these inputs, and prints no break-even. A both-fail probability above the single-source probability is rejected outright: both cannot fail more often than one.
- The break-even probability exceeds 100%. A probability cannot go above 100%, so instead of printing “104.9%” the tool says that no outage probability can justify this cost.
- The amortisation period is 0. The set-up cost cannot be spread over years, so nothing is calculated and the reason is stated.
- Daily cost is 0, or switch-over is not shorter than the outage. A second source then cannot shorten anything, so the tool names that reason, reports no risk reduction and prints no break-even rather than a meaningless figure.
- The recurring cost eats the saving. Payback on the one-off set-up is the set-up cost divided by the annual risk saving minus the recurring annual cost. If that difference is zero or negative there is no payback, and the tool says so instead of returning a negative number of years.
How we handle this
On our side the same calculation runs in the other direction: if we can only supply an item from a single source, we say so in the quote, because the buyer’s risk is our risk too. On critical lines we take written stock and lead-time confirmation before quoting, and where an equivalent is acceptable we price a second channel in advance.
If your enquiry contains an item that depends on a single source, say so when you request a quote — we will separate the lines that have an alternative from the ones that do not, and put them on separate lead times.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is single sourcing wrong?
No. Keeping the volume in one place pays measurably on price, on transaction cost and on the relationship. What is wrong is not putting a number against the cost of an interruption. The decision is made item by item: on a shelf consumable single sourcing can be defensible, on a critical part with no substitute it carries the most risk — the calculator puts a number on which side an item falls.
What does building a second supplier cost?
Two things, and the second is easily forgotten. The one-off set-up is samples, testing, audit, certification and paperwork. The annual cost of keeping it alive is the discount lost when volume is split, a second quality file, a keep-alive order and the extra warehouse record that two non-identical products create. The calculator asks for the two separately, because set-up is paid once and upkeep every year.
If I have two suppliers, is the risk really halved?
Only if the two are independent of each other. Two distributors for the same manufacturer, two importers using the same port, or two producers depending on the same raw material are a single source with two invoices. The value of a second source is not in the number of names but in where it differs: a different manufacturer, a different country, a different port or a different raw material.
How am I supposed to know the outage probability?
It is not measured, it is estimated — but the estimate is not groundless. How many deliveries ran late last year, how many times the supplier said “out of stock”, whether production sits in one plant, whether imports come through one port, whether there is any signal about the supplier’s finances. The break-even output exists to manage that uncertainty: instead of pinning down a probability, you look at the threshold where the decision turns and ask which side of it you are on.
What exactly is the break-even probability?
It is the probability that both sources fail, plus the annual cost of the second source divided by the days a second source saves you on an interruption, priced at the daily cost ((outage days − switch-over days) × daily cost). Above that probability a second source pays, assuming the both-fail probability you entered stays as it is. If the ratio comes out above 100% the tool says so in words, because no realistic probability could justify that cost.
What should I do if a second source does not pay?
Take one of three cheap measures rather than ignoring the risk: keep an approved standby supplier without regular orders, hold targeted safety stock only on the critical items, and write into the contract an obligation on the supplier to give advance warning of a stock-out. All three cost a fraction of a real second source.
For how many items should I build a second source?
Probably fewer than you think. Of the four cells in the risk matrix only one — high impact and few alternatives — earns a real second source. In the other three the answer is already known: plentiful alternatives and low impact means do nothing, few alternatives and low impact is solved with stock, and high impact with plentiful alternatives needs only an approved standby.
Sources
- Method note — the calculator on this page contains no market values of any kind: outage probability, the cost of a day of downtime, freight unit rates and inventory carrying rates vary from company to company, from item to item and from month to month. The figures preset in the fields are examples chosen so the tool does not open empty; they are not benchmarks and they make no claim to be an industry average
How we choose sources, verify figures and date our pages is set out in how we source and verify what we publish. Spotted an error? Write to info@aksco.com.tr — verified errors are corrected.
Related guides
Single-Supplier Consolidation: 8 Advantages
The other side of the coin: what concentrating volume wins.
Read moreSupplier Evaluation Scorecard
The criteria to choose a second source on.
Read moreSpare Parts Min/Max and Reorder Point Calculator
The case where stock replaces a second source.
Read moreOriginal or Equivalent: Making the Call Line by Line
What to do when the second source’s goods are not identical.
Read moreSend your list — your quote is ready within 1 business day.
A list, a photo or an Excel file — whatever is easiest. On standard items we aim to quote the same business day. Custom production, imports or 50+ line lists can take longer; when they do, we tell you the timeline in writing on the day we receive the request.